With so many styles, materials, and brands available, finding the right option can be challenging but the right dog harness recommendations can simplify the process.
How do I choose the right dog harness?
By focusing on your dog’s build, behavior, walking habits, and the intended purpose of the harness, along with the materials used, you can confidently choose the best fit for safety, comfort, and control.
Why Harness Materials Matter
The materials used in a harness are often overlooked but are just as critical as its design. They directly impact your dog’s comfort, skin health, temperature regulation, and safety during walks. Here’s a breakdown of the most common materials:
Neoprene
A top choice for many harnesses, neoprene is durable, hypoallergenic, quick-drying, and resistant to mold and bacteria. It offers soft cushioning without irritating sensitive skin or causing hair loss - making it ideal for active dogs or those prone to skin issues.
Polyester Mesh
Lightweight and breathable, polyester mesh is ideal for warmer climates as it promotes airflow and helps prevent overheating. It’s a smart choice for small breeds or dogs prone to heat sensitivity. However, polyester mesh harnesses tend to stretch, loosen, and wear down over time, and are not considered durable or long-lasting. For this reason, they are not recommended for strong dogs or heavy pullers who require more robust support.
Ripstop Fabric
Ripstop fabric is a tightly woven material reinforced with thicker threads woven in a visible criss-cross or grid pattern, making it easy to identify at a glance. This structure is designed to stop small tears from spreading, which is why ripstop is widely used in backpacks, tents, kites, outdoor gear, and military equipment.
While ripstop is extremely durable, tear-resistant, and lightweight, it offers little to no breathability. The dense weave traps heat and restricts airflow, which can cause discomfort and overheating when worn close to the body, especially for dogs.
Ripstop fabric is sometimes used in human apparel, such as windbreakers, cargo pants, hiking jackets, and outer shells, but typically in loose-fitting or outerwear applications rather than garments worn tightly against the skin. These items are designed for durability and weather resistance, not prolonged skin contact or cooling.
For this reason, ripstop is not recommended for dog harnesses, particularly for heat-sensitive breeds or everyday wear. While strong and long-lasting, its lack of airflow and rigid feel make it better suited for bags, outdoor accessories, and equipment, rather than something a living being wears for extended periods.
Nylon and Polyester Webbing
Strong, durable, and easy to clean, these materials are excellent for everyday use and rugged outdoor adventures. However, without padding, they can cause chafing and be uncomfortable for your dog especially when worn for longer periods.
Biothane and Leather
These materials are waterproof, easy to clean, and mold to your dog’s shape over time. But they tend to be heavier and less breathable, and may cause rubbing, chafing, or hair loss if not closely monitored.
Fleece or Flannel Linings
While cozy, these linings trap heat and can lead to overheating - especially problematic for dogs that are heat sensitive or live in hot climates.
It’s also worth noting that some popular and widely available dog harnesses on the market use ripstop fabric combined with a fleece or padded interior lining. While this construction may provide a cushioned feel, the ripstop outer layer is not designed to allow airflow, and the added lining can further limit ventilation. As a result, these harnesses may retain heat and moisture during wear, especially in warmer conditions or with active dogs. When selecting a harness, it can be helpful to consider materials specifically designed to support breathability and temperature regulation, particularly for dogs that are heat-sensitive or wear a harness for extended periods.
When choosing a harness, take your dog’s unique build into account - such as barrel-chested breeds like French Bulldogs or more delicate dogs like Chihuahuas - as well as their temperament, health, heat sensitivity, and walking behavior.
---
Why Fit and Adjustability Are Critical
Regardless of style, a harness must be properly fitted and adjusted for your dog’s safety and comfort.
- Pressure Distribution: A well-fitted harness evenly spreads pressure across the chest and shoulders, reducing strain on the neck and spine - vital for dogs prone to tracheal collapse or spinal issues.
-
Training Effectiveness: Poorly fitted harnesses can shift or rub, making no-pull training ineffective. Proper adjustments help maintain optimal positioning.
- Escape Prevention: A loose harness makes it easier for your dog to slip out. A snug, adjustable fit is essential.
- Durability: A properly fitted harness resists wear and tear better, extending its life and maintaining performance.
---
Setting the Right Expectations
Choosing a harness isn’t just about looks - it’s about matching the right design to your dog’s unique needs. Whether you’re training a puppy, managing a puller, or seeking a reliable everyday harness, the right fit makes every walk more enjoyable for both you and your dog.
---
1. No Pull Dog Harness (Dual-Clip Harness)
What Is a No Pull Dog Harness?
Designed to reduce pulling, this harness type typically features two leash attachment points - one at the front (chest) and one on the back. The front clip, when properly placed on the chest bone, redirects your dog’s forward momentum back toward you, encouraging better leash manners.
A true no pull harness should include a padded chest panel for added comfort, safety and effectiveness - especially for dogs that tend to pull.
Origin and Evolution
No pull harnesses have been around for decades, evolving from basic strap designs into advanced models with breathable mesh, strategic padding, and multiple adjustment points - all supporting humane, force-free training techniques.
Why Fit Matters for No Pull Training
- Comfort and Safety: Padding and proper fit reduce pressure on the chest, neck, and spine - important for breeds with predisposed medical conditions such as respiratory issues.
- Training Effectiveness: Without a proper fit, the front clip can't redirect effectively and the harness may shift during walks.
- Escape Prevention: Harnesses that aren’t snug at both the neck and chest can allow dogs to slip out - especially strong-willed ones.
✅ Benefits ✅
✅ Versatile fit for many breeds
✅ Some models reduce choking and airway pressure
✅ Ideal for training leash manners
✅ Dual clips for flexibility
✅ Some models include a handle for added control
✅ Some models have breathable and padded interiors
✅ Some models are adjustable at the neck and chest
✅ Neck buckle options for head-shy dogs
✅ Built to handle strong, energetic dogs
✅ Durable and long-lasting
❌ Drawbacks ❌
❌ May not fit very small breeds securely
❌ Some models are not ideal for neckless or toy breeds
❌ Some models can be too bulky for young puppies
❌ Some models retain heat in warm weather
❌ Improper sizing or fit can cause chafing or irritation
❌ Prolonged front-clip use may affect gait
Recommended Breeds
- Barrel-chested: French Bulldogs, Boston Terriers, Pugs
- Energetic: Labradors, Goldens, Shepherds
- Strong pullers: Boxers, Huskies, Pit Bulls
- Smaller breeds: Dachshunds, Yorkies (with proper fit)
- Puppies: Great for teaching early leash manners
Recommended Harnesses
- Wag Trendz No Pull Harness – For dogs 6–75 lbs
- Wag Trendz NeoCool™ Sport Harness - No Pull - For Dogs 6-75 lbs
- Wag Trendz No Pull Harness with Handle – For dogs 25–130 lbs
- Wag Trendz NeoCool™ Sport Harness With Handle - No Pull - For dogs 25–130 lbs
---
2. Roman Style Dog Harness (aka H/Y-Harness)
What Is A Roman Style Dog Harness?
A strap-based design with two loops - around the neck and chest - connected by a strap between the front legs. These harnesses prioritize comfort and freedom of movement rather than no-pull correction.
Origin and Evolution
Rooted in European working-dog gear, the Roman harness was designed to give handlers control while allowing dogs to move freely - ideal for active or well-trained dogs.
H vs. Y Style
- Y-Harness (V-neck): Offers better tracheal protection
- H-Harness (crew neck): Solid pressure distribution but less airway protection
Not a No-Pull Training Tool
Unless outfitted with a reinforced, padded chest and chest clip positioned directly on the breastbone, Roman harnesses are not ideal for pull correction.
✅ Benefits ✅
✅ Allows full range of motion
✅ Lightweight and breathable
✅ Fast on/off with minimal bulk
✅ Available with extra adjustment points
✅ Better airflow than padded harnesses
✅ Great for layering
❌ Drawbacks ❌
❌ Can cause armpit chafing if poorly fitted
❌ Not suitable for pullers
❌ May loosen over time
❌ Often lacks padding for comfort on long walks
❌ May not offer enough control for large breeds
Recommended Breeds
- Small to medium breeds: Beagles, Schnauzers, Westies, Dachshunds
- Barrel-chested (non-pullers): Bulldogs, Frenchies, and Pugs
- Long-backed: Dachshunds, with added chest support
- Trained dogs: Calm walkers with leash manners
Recommended Harnesses
- Wag Trendz H Harness – For dogs that pull minimally
- Blue-9 Balance Harness – Lightweight and fully adjustable
---
3. Step-In Dog Harness
What Is A Step-In Dog Harness?
A step-in dog harness is designed so your dog simply steps into two loops, and the harness fastens on the back - making it ideal for dogs who dislike gear going over their heads.
By design, the harness sits in the dog’s armpits, so the choice of material and construction is crucial when selecting a step-in style. For this reason, step-in harnesses are generally recommended only for small to small-medium dogs.
Dogs that are prone to armpit chafing or sensitive to having somethings in their armpit should avoid this style altogether.
Why A Step In Dog Harness?
Perfect for small breeds, puppies, or dogs with short necks. However, your dog must stand still while stepping in, which may be difficult for anxious or excitable pups.
Materials
Nylon: Durable and washable
Polyester mesh: Lightweight and breathable
Neoprene: Soft, water-resistant, hypoallergenic
Leather/vegan leather: Stylish but less breathable
✅ Benefits ✅
✅ Great for tiny/small dogs
✅ Quick and easy to put on
✅ Perfect for head-shy dogs
✅ Ideal for puppies and senior dogs
✅ Some models are breathable and lightweight
❌ Drawbacks ❌
❌ Requires stillness during fitting
❌ Not ideal for dogs sensitive to paw handling
❌ May cause armpit chafing as harness is designed to sit in the dog's armpit
❌ Not designed for pull control
❌ Can loosen with movement
❌ Often not suited for medium-large to larger breeds
Recommended Breeds
Toy breeds: Chihuahuas, Yorkies, Poms, Toy Poodles
Small breeds: Shih Tzus, Havanese, Cavaliers
Flat-faced breeds: Pekingese, Boston Terriers (check fit)
Slim/light breeds: Italian Greyhounds, Mini Pinschers
Recommended Harnesses
- Voyager Step-In Air Harness – Lightweight and breathable
- Puppia Soft Harness – Padded, soft, and stylish
---
4. Norwegian Style Harness (Horizontal Chest Strap)
What Is It?
This harness wraps around the shoulders and chest but includes a horizontal strap across the front. Though popular for its sleek look, it presents serious anatomical concerns.
History
Originally adapted from horse harnesses used to encourage pulling carts and carriages - not ideal for a dog’s anatomy or movement. This type of harnesses (padded or not) should not be used for any dog breed but especially brachecyphelic breeds who are predisposed to breathing issues.
Why to Avoid It
- Restricted movement: Limits full shoulder extension
- Tracheal pressure: Can irritate the throat and trachea leading to long-term irreversible damage as it encourages pulling
- Horizontal Chest Strap: shifts and moves too much and is oftentimes sitting lopsided on the dog
- Escape risk: Easy to slip out of when poorly fitted and adjusted
- Not for training: No chest clip or redirection control, if there is one - do not use it
- Poor fit: Not designed for dogs and encourages pulling behavior.
✅ Benefits ✅
✅ Simple, minimal-strap design
✅ Easy to put on
✅ Adjustable
✅ Some allow for personalization
❌ Drawbacks ❌
❌ Restricts natural shoulder and leg mobility leading to long-term gait issues
❌ Can cause prolonged and irreversible tracheal issues
❌ Not designed for pull control (harness is designed to encourage pulling)
❌ May chafe under arms
❌ Oftentimes, the horizontal neck strap sits lopsided on the dog leading to poor mobility issues
❌ High escape potential
❌ Loosens with movement
❌Not breathable
Recommended Breeds
None. The drawbacks outweigh any potential benefits. Opt for safer, anatomically supportive styles like Roman harnesses or dual-clip models.
---
Key Considerations When Choosing a Harness
1. Build & Size
Match the harness to your dog’s chest depth, frame, and proportions.
2. Material & Breathability
Choose hypoallergenic, quick-drying, and breathable materials like neoprene or mesh - especially in warm climates. The NEW NeoCool™ Sport Harness, is perfect for keeping your pup cool and comfortable!
3. Temperament & Behavior
Head-shy, anxious, or highly energetic dogs may benefit from specific features like step-in access or front-clip control.
4. Purpose & Activity Level
Pick a harness tailored to your lifestyle—training, hiking, daily strolls, or control.
5. Fit & Adjustability
Ensure proper neck and chest adjustments. Look for reinforced hardware and breathable padding.
6. Durability
High-quality materials are a smart investment for strong or active dogs.
---
Final Recommendations by Need
- Strong Pullers: Wag Trendz No Pull Dual-Clip Harness
- Heat Sensitive/Active Dogs: Wag Trendz NeoCool™ Sport Harness
- Occasional Pullers: Robust Y-Harness
- Calm Dogs: Wag Trendz H-Style or Blue-9 Balance Harness
- Tiny/Sensitive Dogs: Voyager Step-In Air Harness
- Unusual Builds: Adjustable Y or H harnesses
---
Conclusion: Simplifying Your Dog Harness Choice
Choosing the right dog harness is essential for your dog’s comfort, safety, and happiness. By focusing on build, behavior, and lifestyle needs, you can confidently select a harness that improves every walk - for both of you.
---
Ready to choose?
Explore trusted options like the Wag Trendz Dual-Clip No Pull Harness for pullers, or the Voyager Step-In Harness for small breeds. Still unsure? Ask a professional trainer or vet for personalized guidance.
Happy walking - here’s to stress-free, tail-wagging adventures!
